Advantages of natural gas
Natural gas is abundant and produces far less greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) - other than the potent GHG methane (a notable caveat) - when it's burned for energy as compared to coal. Natural gas reservoirs in vast shale rock formations underground have been discovered and developed. How much lower are GHGs from natural gas than coal? The difference is dramatic, making natural gas a much cleaner-burning energy alternative compared to coal (although compared to renewable energy generation for electricity, natural gas is still not really optimally "clean").
According to the Worldwatch Institute, natural gas energy generation emits about half the amount of GHGs as coal (although natural gas combustion produces the much more potent GHG methane in higher amounts than coal). This stat includes taking a variety of factors into account, such as methane flares and methane leaks associated with natural gas vs. the quantity of GHGs associated with coal. Another upside of energy from natural gas is that, like solar and wind, natural gas is less expensive than coal in every stage of energy production of the fuel source.
The countries that produce the most gas are the United States and Russia; with the natural gas-producing countries China, Canada, Saudi Arabia, Norway, and Australia, combined, not producing as much gas as the U.S. and Russia each do individually. The countries and regions that consume the most natural gas, after the United States (which consumes over 20% of the world's gas), are the EU nations and Russia, with Germany individually being the highest gas-consuming EU nation. However, Germany still consumes less natural gas energy than Canada, Saudi Arabia, Japan, and Mexico.
Greenhouse gas reductions with natural gas
The United States actually reduced its GHGs back to 1996 levels a decade ago; by more than 12% (as of 2013), largely due to a focus on natural gas energy generation. Much of the credit for the GHG reduction in the United States in the 21st-century has been attributed to a significant shift from coal to natural gas to power major U.S. electrical utilities.
Coal has fallen from supplying over 50% of U.S. total energy output at the turn of the century, to less than 20%. Natural gas has increased from 15% to around 40% of overall United States energy production in that same time period. Because natural gas burns cleaner than coal, this shift to more gas than coal combustion for U.S. energy has without a doubt been a factor in the reduction of GHGs being pumped into the atmosphere.
Note - other factors have reduced the overall production of GHGs in the U.S. as well; increased fuel efficiency in vehicles, use of sustainable public mass transit, fewer vehicles on the road due to increased use of public transit and ride-sharing services, and increased use of green building and energy efficiency technologies. Still, the reduction of coal usage and the increase of natural gas is a significant influence on the reduction of GHGs.
Methane from natural gas stays in the atmosphere for a shorter duration than carbon dioxide (CO2), and other GHGs from coal combustion (CO2 is the most significant GHG associated with coal). Methane is a more destructive GHG to the earth's atmosphere (methane is far more potent than carbon dioxide). However, the quantity of CO2 and other GHGs produced with burning coal is significantly higher with coal, than with natural gas.
Natural Gas is Cleaner and more efficient than coal
In addition to burning cleaner than coal, natural gas (along with renewable energy from wind and solar) has been determined to be less expensive overall than all other forms of energy generation when looking at the levelized cost of energy (LCOE); as seen in this study by the University of Texas at Austin Energy Institute. Natural gas also integrates seamlessly when paired with renewable energy and energy storage.
Natural gas power plants can use integrated gas combined cycle (IGCC) technologies, and even emerging CCS technologies to produce cleaner energy. Gas plants can combine to work in synergy with solar and solar thermal and energy storage in power plants. When natural gas is used in these capacities, it is certainly a clean(er) energy technology (although burning natural gas still produces GHG emissions). Natural gas "peaker" power plants provide back-up energy to renewable power plants during peak times of energy demand, or provide energy from the hybrid plant to the grid in lieu of energy storage.
In the United States, over 30% of natural gas is generated using advanced combined-cycle gas generation; and that share of the U.S. gas market for the lower cost, higher efficiency advanced gas combined-cycle plants is increasing.
In addition to having a lower LCOE, natural gas also represents a significant source of employment, income, and revenue to the U.S. economy. Although natural gas is still a fossil fuel, natural gas can be part of a clean energy project by efficiently integrating with renewable energy and energy storage (see the hybrid Martin County power plant pictured above). Such hybrid power plants certainly exemplify clean energy technologies creating jobs in the US economy. Clean energy jobs provide a needed boost to the economy.
Another advantage of gas is that natural gas rigs tend to be less obtrusive within the environment when compared to mountaintop removal coal mining, strip mining, and the large-scale terraced pits of major coal operations. Coal is still an abundant form of energy; and it’s still relatively cheap to burn when the energy distribution remains close to the coal power plant (although, burning coal does become more and more expensive as GHG reducing technologies like carbon capture and storage (CCS) are employed in the burning of coal - and 'clean coal' technologies like CCS are certainly necessary in order to even consider burning coal for energy). Technologies like CCS and IGCC significantly reduce GHG emissions from the production of energy when applied to the burning of coal for energy.
The biggest of the MANY significant drawbacks of coal is that, while being abundant, it is also among the dirtiest forms of energy (only tar-sand crude oil is dirtier). Coal emits a tremendous amount of GHGs, and also emits fine particulates, which cause public health hazards and are a danger to wildlife and the environment.
In order to mitigate anthropogenic climate change, the energy generation sector must be focused on ways to reduce pollutants; such as 'clean coal' technologies like CCS and IGCC. Although these technologies don't actually turn coal plants into clean power plants, they do become considerably cleaner than plants without these technologies.
In burning coal for energy, the many negative externalities of coal (such as: contributing significantly to climate change, damage to public health, damage to plant and animal ecosystems, and other damage to the environment from coal pollution) must be considered; external costs which add dramatically to the economic and social cost of coal.
Controversies with natural gas
Of course, the boom in natural gas production has not been without controversy. The process of hydraulic fracturing (fracking - the process of extracting natural gas from shale rock) has spawned widespread protest, especially from environmental groups, because the process is tremendously damaging to the environment. Fracking requires enormous amounts of water, which is mixed with huge quantities of silica, and a large variety of toxic chemicals, to be injected deep underground; causing minor earthquakes, frequent leaks of methane from natural gas rigs, and leaks of other toxic chemicals from fracking operations that get into freshwater supplies, causing damage to ecosystems, animal, and human health. Here's a list of 20 negative impacts of fracking on the environment. It must be noted that coal is worse for the environment.
Please see: Energy Storage
and Power to Gas - renewable energy storage, and fuel for the grid
GCT Featured Articles
Oslo, Norway – Eco-Capital
Oslo: Net Zero Future | Oslo has fleets of clean mass public transit - trams, electric buses and ferries - powered...Read Post
Regenerative agriculture creates carbon sinks; turning farms into healthy ecosystems that sequester carbon with plentiful...Read Post
Sustainable City – CHICAGO
Chicago might not be widely known as a green city, however, the city has a vast network of sustainable mass public transit...Read Post
Vauban and the Plus-Energy Sun Ship
Vauban is an exemplary sustainable town and a zero-emission district. Most energy for buildings is from rooftop solar...Read Post
Climate Solution – Sustainable Agriculture
Benefits of Sustainable Agriculture | Sustainable ag. turns farms into thriving biodiverse lands that produce...Read Post
Austin, Texas – A Sustainable City
Eco-friendly Capital | Austin is emerging as a leader in renewable energy, community solar, and LEED building efficiency...Read Post
12+ Ways You Can Help the Environment
Lower your carbon footprint, save energy, and help the environment. Here are 12+ actions for sustainable individuals:...Read Post
10 Ways to Reduce Food Waste
by Jane Marsh | Significant amounts of food waste originate from cities. Urbanites can use food waste reduction methods...Read Post
Modern Sustainable Waste Management Technologies
5 Ways for SMART Cities to Implement Sustainable Waste Management | by Jane Marsh | Cities are implementing zero-waste...Read Post
5 Categories of Change in Climate
Climate change is adversely affecting all parts of the earth. There have been dramatic increases in greenhouse gas emissions...Read Post
10 IoT and Sustainability Technologies for Smart Cities
Technologies Benefit Sustainable Smart Cities | by Jane Marsh | As the conversation around greenhouse gas emissions...Read Post
Profiles in Sustainable Cities – San Diego, California
Sustainable cities, like San Diego, have eco-city designs that prioritize consideration of social, economic, and environmental...Read Post
Offshore Wind Farms in the United States | Block Island Leads the Way
First of many US offshore wind farms | The United States' 1st operational offshore wind farm is the Block Island...Read Post
Clean Energy Jobs are UP, and RE cost is down
Clean Energy JOBS | The future of employment in the energy sector is in clean energy, energy efficiency, and renewable...Read Post
Using Technology to Provide Clean Water to Cities
How Technology Can Help Cities Avoid Another Flint Water Crisis | Article by Jane Marsh | The green movement is influencing...Read Post
How Safe & Clean is Nuclear ☢️ Energy?
When looking at climate solutions for clean energy generation, it is prudent to look at all clean energy sources. Nuclear...Read Post
Kamuthi Solar Project, Bhadla Solar Park; and the largest solar PV farms in India, China, and other countries
Featuring over 2.5 million individual solar PV modules, and on 2,500 acres, the Kamuthi Solar Power Project supplies...Read Post
Microgrids spread across Africa
Developing Microgrids | As African nations push for rural electrification, many look to microgrids as a sustainable...Read Post
Future Generations of Batteries
Next generation li-ion batteries | Next-gen lithium-ion (li-ion) batteries can charge quickly, are rechargeable,...Read Post
Clean Hydrogen Power
Hydrogen (H2) and the Clean Energy Transition | Hydrogen created with clean energy is one of the most promising...Read Post
Nuclear – necessary energy
Both nuclear and renewable energy are needed in the global energy mix to help fight climate change. In order to cut...Read Post
COP21 – good news for the planet
NDCs and Net Zero Pledges | At COP21, commonly referred to as the Paris Climate Accord, nations sent representatives...Read Post
Plan for the Expansion of Smart Meter Infrastructure
Modern SMART Meters | Many buildings in America today still rely on inefficient energy infrastructure, such as older...Read Post
Recycling – how we are doing as a global community; waste-to-energy
Effective waste management strategies for cities include citywide recycling programs, circular economy strategies, as...Read Post
Permanent ban on new coal mines and other sustainability priorities
Strategies for mitigating climate change | What are the best strategies for mitigating global warming? How is the...Read Post
10 Sustainable Technologies Improving Air Quality in Cities
GREEN Tech for Healthy Air | Article by Jane Marsh | Cities are the heart of every global region. They are headquarters...Read Post
Shortfall in International GHG Reduction Pledges
Is the World Going to Meet its Climate Targets? There is a substantial shortfall between GHG emission reduction pledges...Read Post
The Global Fight Against Climate Change; NDCs and Net Zero Targets Worldwide
Nationally Determined Contributions | As part of the ongoing global battle against climate change, almost 200 countries...Read Post
Breakthroughs in Solar Photovoltaic (PV) and Solar Thermal Technology
Solar - the most abundant renewable energy on the planet | Recently there have been dramatic breakthroughs in solar...Read Post
Renewable Energy – Breakthroughs in Wind Energy
Onshore Wind Farms - Cheap and Clean Energy | Onshore wind farms now provide the least expensive form of energy, renewable...Read Post
Economy vs. the Environment
Economic growth does not have to come at the expense of the environment. Sustainable technologies (such as renewable...Read Post
Desalination – Clean Water for a Thirsty World
The two desalination plants featured below; one in Carlsbad (San Diego county, California - featured photo), and one...Read Post
10 Countries Promoting the use of Electric Vehicles (EVs)
Why Is There A Need For EVs Globally? In its World Energy Outlook, the International Energy Agency identifies pathways...Read Post
Smart City Energy Infrastructure
Updating Infrastructure for Developing Renewable Energy in Cities | People-centered smart cities are cropping up worldwide....Read Post
EVs and the Future of Urban Transit
Electric Vehicle (EV) Infrastructure | What will be done to develop electric vehicle infrastructure? With cars that...Read Post
The Role of E-mobility Trends in Decarbonizing Transport
Decarbonizing the Transportation Sector with E-mobility | It's no secret that transportation is a major source of...Read Post
Putting a Price on Carbon
Carbon Markets | Carbon cap and trade systems are regulatory policies in which countries, provinces, states, and even...Read Post
Deforestation and solutions; including reforestation | Deforestation of our planet, for centuries, has led to issues...Read Post
UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) – Conference of the Parties | World leaders, dignitaries,...Read Post
Carbon tax – a levy on pollution whose time has come
Defining effective carbon taxes | A carbon tax is a levy in countries and regions on: fossil fuel power plants, oil...Read Post
Improving energy efficiency
Energy Efficiency Foundations for Green Building: Energy Star, LED and CFL Lights, LEED technologies When it comes to...Read Post
Decoupling and Divestment to Reach Sustainability
Economic Growth Without Environmental Impact Decoupling in eco-environmental terms can be defined as economic growth...Read Post
ISEGS – A Shining Example of Concentrated Solar Power (CSP)
Ivanpah Solar Electrical Generating System (ISEGS) Ivanpah Solar Electrical Generating System (ISEGS) is a 392 MW solar concentrated...Read Post
Car-sharing and Ride-hailing
Sustainable Commuting | Many ride-sharing fleets are converting to electric cars. Car-sharing (a.k.a. ride-sharing)...Read Post
California – Current Progress of a Climate Champion
Learning From California's Struggle to Balance Decarbonization With Energy Resilience | Since California passed the...Read Post
A Close Look at San Diego’s HERO Program
San Diego, Green Buildings, HERO Program | The importance of green energy for use in homes and businesses is becoming...Read Post
Please let us here at Green City Times know what you think in a comment; and we’ll try and answer any questions as well.
Please also visit our other blog at https://greencitytimes.blogspot.com
[Dan Braff is the founder of GCT –